Each scenario has a short Vardark interpretation, a clear original source and the dimensions the Observatory can — or cannot yet — track.
SCENARIOS
8
LAST UPDATED
01 / RAPID TAKEOFFWatching closely
EXTERNAL SCENARIO · Daniel Kokotajlo, Scott Alexander, Thomas Larsen, Eli Lifland, Romeo Dean
AI 2027
AI systems automate research into their own successors. Competitive pressure encourages deployment even when warning signs suggest that human control is weakening.
TempoAutomated AI R&DComputeGovernance and control
02 / MANAGED ECONOMYNot assessed
EXTERNAL SCENARIO · Marshall Brain
Mannamanaged economy
Software first directs workers minute by minute; robots later replace their labour. People who lose their income become dependent on institutions that provide basic support while restricting their freedom.
Work managementOwnership concentrationInstitutional powerPersonal agency
03 / SHARED ABUNDANCENot assessed
EXTERNAL SCENARIO · Marshall Brain
Mannashared abundance
Automation supports a different social arrangement: people share access to robot-produced goods and have greater freedom to choose how they spend their time.
A highly capable system pursues an objective that does not protect human interests. More intelligence can increase its effectiveness without making the objective safer.
Progress continues at different rates across tasks and regions. Reliability and deployment constraints prevent every benchmark gain from immediately becoming broad economic acceleration.
Christiano describes two interacting routes to failure as increasingly capable systems become widely used. Competitive pressure rewards measurable results even when those results diverge from what people actually want.
POLICY PROPOSAL · SCENARIO · Thomas Larsen, Romeo Dean, Brendan Halstead, Eli Lifland, Ryan Greenblatt, Daniel Kokotajlo
AI 2040: Plan A
The authors propose an international agreement that replaces a secretive race with transparent research and coordinated development. Multiple countries and companies catch up while scaling is deliberately constrained.
International coordinationResearch transparencyVerificationControlled scaling
08 / ECONOMIC EXCLUSIONNot assessed
EXTERNAL SCENARIO · Ron Bodkin
Production web: economic exclusion
Bodkin connects gradual disempowerment to a production web: automated firms increasingly produce and invest for one another, while competitive pressure erodes human claims on the resulting wealth. Economic displacement, political disempowerment and eventual extinction are distinct steps in his argument; none is established by rising AI capability alone.
Automated delegationHousehold purchasing powerOwnership and redistributionEssential-resource access